Last time my friend was also asked to pay for the labor charge. He is pretty innocet, and he paid for the labor charge. When he showed me the bill, i shouted at him and told himt o clain against it. Its not fair. He went back to the dealer, and reported a complain against them. The executive officer then apologized to him for the same, but he did not get his money back. But out of all this mess, me and me hyfriend understood that one does not have to pay for the labor charge to your dealer if your car is under warranty issued by the same dealer.