Hi @samamara
first of all thank you for your post , yet useful discussion indeed for all .It is always not an easy decision when it comes to which is best.
last year I came across similar cross road of what to choose and my second hand short list was Wrangler , Pagero and Xterra drove all of them as test drive ending up with 2012 Xterra. all the three were apparently clean after checking and at that time I didn’t want to spend lots of money so I found the Xterra the best of both world ( driving me to work and back home with daily almost 70 km on average , comfortable enough as a single driver , as well as my weekly desert capable powerful machine in sand terrain ) . Squeezing leaves was never a problem with regular steam wash😊
however if it’s a bank funded brand new I would have gone straight away for the Super safari SWB .
If I am a fan of wadi and photography then its the rubicon no doubt be it SWB or LWB it’s your choice of space and number of passengers you would like to carry with you , not mentioning the handy removal of roofs doors .. etc and tons of mods “ RTA approved “ annual registration headache free and warranty .. etc
FJ is great off-roader but i am too claustrophobic for daily use as well as visibility was important as I was at the beginning of the learning curve. So it was out of my choice regardless new or sec hand .
my humble advice : short list your needs against the short list of the available options in the light of the different opinions ( another reason why I like this unbiased community ) and I hope you get best what you are looking for .
best of luck 🙏
Mohamed