Jump to content

Jeep General Discussion Forum | Jeep Cherokee Forum | Jeep Commander Forum | Jeep Grand Cherokee Forum | Jeep Liberty Forum | Jeep Patriot Forum | Jeep Wrangler Forum

nik5111

Can anyone suggest if new 8 speed Automatic Jeep is better than old 5 Speed, also considering the price difference

Recommended Posts

Can anyone suggest if new 8 speed Automatic Jeep is better than old 5 Speed, also considering the price difference

 

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Newer technology is always better being more efficient, performing and sometimes more reliable than older ones.

Maybe you can share some more details instead of assuming that everyone is thinking what you are thinking, quite natural while hunting your next car, lol

I think it's wrangler JK VS JL you are asking.....? Correct me if I'm wrong and also put pricing vs benefits so that people can advise further

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

8 speed should be indeed much better on the road, as you can cruise in lower revs on the highway, resulting in lower consumption.

For Offroading i am however not so sure if it makes that much of a difference. I am afraid it would be shifting too much constantly in D mode, and it would perform better in tiptronic mode so you can select manually which gear works best for your purposes.

 

  • Like 1
  • Thanks 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Great question @Frederic and although i do not have any idea but the 8 speed would be much better than the CVT gears.

Moreover the 8 speed gear in a Jeep with their off-road capability i am sure the makers would have kept that in consideration and it would perform just as well in the desert.

If you do not get the feedback here, you can always test drive a Jeep in 4H and pump the accelerator to get a feel of the gear shift. I have a friend in Jeep sales at Festival City, I can pass on his name to you on one of the drives.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I am with @Frederic on this one.

I am assuming you meant the Jeep JK vs the JL, the later being the newest version of the jeep.

It would really depend if you will be using the jeep off-road or just for daily commute. In a few words 5 speed is better off-road and the 8 speed is better on highway.

The 8 speed claims to reduce fuel consumption by 9% over the 5 speed transmission but I doubt it is for the transmission, I think is because JL has an aluminum body as opposed the steel body of the JK, making the JL lighter and therefore improving fuel consumption. I think that for on-road driving will definitely benefit from the 3 extra speeds since you will run in lower revs. 

However, when it comes to off-road keep in mind this 8 speed transmission is used in the Ram 1500 and Grand Cherokee, cars that are not necessarily made for off-road like the Wrangler this is a transmission that is not properly tested off-road. They are only installing this transmission for cost purposes and they are not thinking about the reliability. 

In off-road conditions simpler is always better, unless you use the 8 speed in triptronic it will be under much more stress than the 5 speed.

  • Like 3

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Similar Content

    • By Jebal Alandalus
      We provide special pricing for all Carnity members.
      Jebal Alandalus Used Auto Spare Parts Trading is based in Sharjah Al Sajaa area since 2016, we are specialist in all types of used parts for Ford, Kia, Hyundai, Nissan, Toyota, Honda, GMC, Jeep, Infiniti. We have all genuine parts in good condition. We have well trained staff who does their work in proper time to give the best service to our customers.
      Please feel free to contact on below numbers.
      Whatsapp -055 783 6557
      Call- 055 885 5570, 052 354 4437, 055 906 2391
      For Recovery Please Call- 055 990 0940
    • By Gaurav
      I personally know 3 girls, who have bought wrangler for fun without knowing it's specs or offroad capabilities.
      And they take their Wranglers to work every day and never stepped in sand or rocks.
      I'm really curious to know why.......?
       
       
    • By Jocreative
      It's topless season! For Jeeps I mean! 
      Along with that came the unwelcome guest - Stray cats.  
      They have always been around no matter where you are in the UAE... keep your car in a covered parking in apartment building or park it outside, chances are you have this visitor sitting on your warm vehicle, taking creative liberty and leaving foot prints all over the windshield, trunk and roof. And if you are lucky... it will pee and/or leave scratches on your seat! 
      Something had to be done... so I started looking for solutions... Cat Repellent Solutions... Cat have very sensitive sense of smell, so you spray some pungent odor stuff around, it can keep them away. 

      This DIY recipe that worked for me -  Water + Vinegar + Eucalyptus + Garlic + Rosemary = Mix all this good stuff up in a spray bottle and Viola! 
      Spray them periodically around your Jeep or car or bike and you will not be bothered again. 
      It worked for me so hope it helps others
       

    • By Jocreative
      Traditionally, in order to disable your ABS/ESC control, you have to do the voodoo "steering wheel dance" or pull out the J6 fuse from the fuse box.
      Well, pulling out the fuse a few times broke my fuse puller! So, I started looking out for alternatives and finally found a solution. 
      There are two ways to do it.  
      One (most common method you find on youtube videos) is to intercept the wire from under the gear box... this method is tideous as it involves pulling out the 4HiLo gear knob out. This method is a serious pain-in-the-rearo! Good luck if you chose this method.. this post is not for you.

      Second method, is to intercept the same wire from the source, which is located under the hood. Much easier. 

      Here is a brief write up of how I have done it.

      Things you need: 
      1. Any On/Off Switch. I used an accessory push on/off button. 
      2. 1-1.5m of electrical accessory wire.
      3. Insulation Tape
      4. Wire strippers and Wire connectors. 
      5. Handy Drill with drill bit.
      6. Lots of patience, Sane enough to Cut the right Wire and a Steady Hand. 
      DISCLAIMER: I do not take any responsibility in case you snip the wrong wire or short anything else in the process. Do it at your own risk.  
      Another Disclaimer:  This is a quick and dirty tutorial for a kill switch. Make necessary adjustments in case you want a cleaner safer way.   
      Yet another Disclaimer: Apologies for the dusty pictures. Hope they help illustrate the steps! 

      Okey, now that's out of the way, here we go - 
      1. Locate the ESP unit under your Wrangler hood. This is usually near the Brake fluid area. Push the lock pins on either side to release the latch and it swings up to unlock. ( Fig 1 ) 
      2. Unplug two more plugs that branch out from the same harness ( Fig 2 ). After doing this, its easier to pull out the entire harness from underneath the unit and towards you so that you can see it clear. 
      3.  Remove the stock wraps and insulation from the thick main harness to expose the wires. Locate the Purple with light blue wire. Make sure its the right one because there is also another purple with dark blue (leave it alone!). 
      4. Snip the Purple with Blue stripe wire. ( If you want to make sure you cut the right wire, you can plug everything back in, turn the car on, and it will show the ABS and Traction Symbols on the dash. Pat yourself in the back! If not, and some other symbols show, then go back to step 3 and make sure you cut the right wire! )
      5. Attach some wire connectors to the ends of the striped wire. This is so that in case, in the future, you decide you do not want the switch, or you want to swap it out with something else, you can quickly do it. 
      6. Drill a hole wherever you decide to place the switch. Fasten the switch to the panel. Place a metal washer behind the switch so that it doesn't press on to the cowl every time you push it. Some recommend placing metal plates, but am lazy... this is supposed to be the easy tutorial, right?  
      7. Feed the switch wires through the firewall hole (fig# 4 & 5). You can fetch it from underneath the dash panel. Feed it through the right compartments to where you need it to come out.  
      (PS: If you have already soldered the wire to the switch, then do step 6 in reverse. Feed a shoe lace or wire-puller-of-your-choice through the firewall and fetch the wire in from the dash side to the hood) 
      8. Attach +ve end of the switch wire to one end of the snipped wire and the -ve end to the other snipped end. It doesn't matter if you get the +ve and -ve reversed as you are just extending the connection from the same wire and not dealing with a +ve or -ve literally. 
      9. Once all the switch and connections are tested and verified, insulate and wrap the wires back. Make sure no wire or metal contacts are exposed. Secure with zip ties where ever necessary. (Fig6 shown for reference but I wrapped the exposed contact later with insulation tape)
      10. Close everything back and go through all the work again to make sure everything is where its supposed to be. 
      The Switch pushed in, means the wire is connected, so your ABS and ESC is active. 
      When the switch is in the OFF position, there is a break in the connection, so your ABS/ESC will be inactive. Fig 7 shows a rough wire diagram. 
      To Reset the warning lights on your dash, turn the car off, push the switch to ON position and the ABS/ESC lights should go off. 

      Safety note: 
      Activate the switches ONLY WHEN CAR IDLE. DO NOTE activate while driving or you may end up doing some unexpected drifting or donuts!  
      Tutorial only applicable for JK (07-18) Wrangler models. Refer to your manual for wire codes if needed.  

      Enjoy and Safe Off-Roading!
      Follow @joshmyster on instagram in case you found this tutorial helpful. 
       








×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

Terms of use